The status of the issue of forensic medical diagnosis of drowning and determination of the duration of the corpse's stay in the water (literature review)



Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Abstract

The article discusses the status of the issue of forensic medical diagnosis of drowning and the establishment of the duration of the corpse's stay in the water. The results of research that confirm the effectiveness of using modern technologies and methods in forensic medicine, contributing to the investigation of the event of the discovery of a corpse in the water, are discussed. With regard to determining the duration of a body's stay in water, the study of maceration of the skin remains the main one. But it is possible to use other methods. For example, it has been found that hair stabilizes its mass after a certain period of exposure to an aquatic environment, but specialized equipment is required to perform such an analysis. The influence of temperature on rotting processes, the rate of which varies depending on environmental conditions, is also considered. An important aspect is the use of histology and microbiological methods to determine the time spent by a corpse in water, as well as the role of algae and other organisms in the decomposition process. The article highlights the need for an integrated approach in forensic medical practice to improve the accuracy of diagnosis of drowning and establish the causes of death.

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Sergey Poltarev

Author for correspondence.
Email: PoltarevSV@zdrav.mos.ru
ORCID iD: 0009-0007-3745-4590

Sergey Shigeev

Email: shigeev@mail.ru

Guzel Karataeva

Email: koshka-gu@yandex.ru

References

  1. Di Giancamillo A. C. Immersion of piglet carcasses in waterthe applicability of microscopic analysis and limits of diatom testing on an animal model / A. Di Giancamillo, E. Giudici, S. Andreola [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2010. – № 12. – R. 13–18.
  2. Byard R. W. Diagnostic problems associated with cadaveric trauma from animal activity / R. W. Byard, R. A. James, J. D. Gilbert // The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 2002. – № 23. – R. 238–244.
  3. Byard R. W. Animals, autopsies and artefacts / R. W. Byard // Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology. – 2011. – № 7. – R. 309–310.
  4. Konoreva A. K. Opredelenie prizhiznennosti i davnosti povrezhdenij na trupah, izvlechyonnyh iz vodoyomov / A. K. Konoreva, S. V. Hasanyanova // Problemy ekspertizy v medicine. – Izhevsk : Ekspertiza, 2010. – №3-4. – S. 55-56.
  5. Van Hoyweghen A. J. Can post-mortem CT reliably distinguish between drowning and non-drowning asphyxiation? / A. J. Van Hoyweghen, W. Jacobs, B. Op de Beeck [et al.] // International Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2015. – № 129. – R. 159–164.
  6. Shkrum M. J. Bodies recovered from water / M. J. Shkrum, D. A. Ramsay. Forensic Pathology of Trauma: Common Problems for the Pathologist. New Jersey: Humana Press; 2007.
  7. Bierens J. J. Physiology of drowning: a review / J. J. Bierens, P. Lunetta, M. Tipton [et al.] // Physiology. – 2016. – № 31. – R. 147–166.
  8. Lunetta P. Autopsy findings: drowning and submersion deaths / P. Lunetta. Second Ed. In: Payne-James J, Byard RW, eds. Encyclopedia of Forensic and Legal Medicine. Vol. 1. Oxford: Academic Press. – 2016. – R. 315–322.
  9. Byard R. W. Commercial fishing industry deaths – forensic issues / R. W. Byard // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2013. – № 20. – R. 129–132.
  10. Carter N. Problems in the interpretation of hemorrhage into neck musculature in cases of drowning / N. Carter, F. Ali, M. A. Green // The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 1998. – № 19. – R. 223–225.
  11. Alexander R. T. Neck and scleral haemorrhage in drowning / R. T. Alexander, J. M. Jentzen // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2011. – № 56. – R. 522–525.
  12. Spitz D. J. Investigation of bodies in water / D. J. Spitz. In: WU Spitz, Spitz DJ, Eds. Spitz and Fisher's Medicolegal Investigation of Death. Fourth Ed. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas; 2006. – R. 846–881.
  13. Wardak K. S. The Drowning index: implementation in drowning, mechanical asphyxia, and acute myocardial infarct cases / K. S. Wardak, R. M. Buchsbaum, F. Walyzada // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2014. – № 59. – R. 399–403.
  14. Reijnen G. Can pulmonary foam arise after postmortem submersion in water? An animal experimental pilot study. / G. Reijnen, P. Vos, M. Buster [et al.] // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2018. – № 61. – R. 40-44.
  15. Vander Plaetsen S. Post-mortem evaluation of drowning with whole body CT. / S. Vander Plaetsen, E. De Letter, M. Piette [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2015. – № 249. – R. 35–41.
  16. Haffner H. T. Spleen findings in drowning. / H. T. Haffner, M. Graw, J. Erdelkamp // Forensic Science International. – 1994. – № 66. – R. 95–104.
  17. Palmiere C. The forensic spleen: morphological, radiological, and toxicological investigations / C. Palmiere, C. Tettamanti, M. P. Scarpelli [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2018. – № 291. – R. 94–99.
  18. Hadley J. A. Organ weight effects of drowning and asphyxiation on the lungs, liver, brain, heart, kidneys, and spleen / J. A. Hadley, D. R. Fowler // Forensic Science International. – 2003. – № 133. – R. 190–196.
  19. Szpilman D. Drowning / D. Szpilman, J. J. Bierens, A. J. Handley [et al.] // The New England Journal of Medicine. – 2012. – № 366. – R. 2102–2110.
  20. Zhu B. L. Postmortem lung weight in drownings: a comparison with acute asphyxiation and cardiac death / B. L. Zhu, L. Quan, D. R. Li [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2003. – № 5. – R. 20–26.
  21. Nishitani Y. Weight ratio of the lungs and pleural effusion to the spleen in the diagnosis of drowning / Y. Nishitani, K. Fujii, S. Okazaki [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2006. – № 8. – R. 22–27.
  22. Morild I. Pleural effusion in drowning / I. Morild // The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 1995. – № 16. – R. 253–256.
  23. Kringsholm B. Autopsied cases of drowning in Denmark 1987-1989 / B. Kringsholm, A. Filskov, K. Kock // Forensic Science International. – 1991. – № 52. – R. 85–92.
  24. Zhu B. L. Lung-heart weight ratio as a possible index of cardiopulmonary pathophysiology in drowning / B. L. Zhu, L. Quan, K. Ishida [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2003. – № 5. – R. 295–297.
  25. Tse R. The potential diagnostic accuracy of autopsy lung weights, lung-heart ratio and lung-body ratio in drowning deaths / R. Tse, J. Garland, K. Kesha [et al.] // The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 2018. – № 39. – R. 223–228.
  26. Sugimura T. Application of the drowning index to actual drowning cases / T. Sugimura, M. Kashiwagi, A. Matsusue [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2010. – № 12. – R. 68–72.
  27. Byard R. W. Aortic intimal staining in drowning / R. W. Byard // Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology. – 2015. – № 11. – R. 442–444.
  28. Byard R. W. Putrefaction: an additional complicating factor in the assessment of freshwater drownings in rivers / R. W. Byard // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2018. – № 63. – R. 899–901.
  29. Tsokos M. Hemolytic staining of the intima of the aortic root in freshwater drowning: a retrospective study / M. Tsokos, G. Cains, R. W. Byard // The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 2008. – № 29. – R. 128–130.
  30. Hyodoh H. Experimental drowning lung images on postmortem CT – difference between sea water and fresh water / H. Hyodoh, R. Terashima, M. Rokukawa [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2016. – № 19. – R. 11–15.
  31. Usui A. Postmortem Lung Features in Drowning Cases on Computed Tomography / A. Usui, Y. Kawasumi, M. Funayama [et al.] // Japanese Journal of Radiology. – 2014. – № 32(7). – R. 414–420.
  32. Chumakova Yu. V. Ustanovlenie sudebno-medicinskih priznakov utopleniya s pomoshch'yu metoda komp'yuternoj tomografii : avtoreferat dissertacii ... kandidata medicinskih nauk : 3.3.5. / Chumakova Yuliya Vadimovna // Rossijskij universitet druzhby narodov imeni Patrisa Lumumby ; Dissovet PDS 0300.011. – Moskva, 2024. – 25 s.
  33. Caspar J. L. Thanatological Division / J. L. Caspar. Ch IV. Death from drowning. A Handbook of the Practice of Forensic Medicine Based upon Personal Experience. Vol. 2. London: The New Sydenham Society; 1862. – R. 229–274.
  34. Krstic S. Diatoms in forensic expertise of drowning – a Macedonian experience / S. Krstic, A. Duma, B. Janevska [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2002. – № 127. – R. 198–203.
  35. Byard R. W. Drowning deaths in rivers / R. W. Byard // Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology. – 2017. – № 13. – R. 388–389.
  36. Lunetta P. False-positive diatom test: a real challenge? A post-mortem study using standardized protocols / P. Lunetta, A. Miettinen, K. Spilling [et al.] // Journal of Legal Medicine. – 2013. – № 15. – R. 229–234.
  37. Kakizaki E. Simple protocol for extracting diatoms from lung tissues of suspected drowning cases within 3 h: first practical application / E. Kakizaki, N. Yukawa // Forensic Science International. – 2015. – № 251. – R. 179–185.
  38. Zhao J. The diagnostic value of quantitative assessment of diatom test for drowning: an analysis of 128 water-related death cases using microwave digestion-vacuum filtration-automated scanning electron microscopy / J. Zhao, C. Liu, A. S. A. Bardeesi [et al.] // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2017. – № 62. – R. 1638–1642.
  39. Piette M. H. A. Drowning: still a difficult autopsy diagnosis / M. H. A. Piette, E. A. De Letter // Forensic Science International. – 2006. – № 163. – R. 1–9.
  40. Lin C. Y. Diatomological investigation in sphenoid sinus and lung tissue from cases of suspected drowning / C. Y. Lin, W. C. Yen, H. M. Hsieh [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2014. – № 244. – R. 111–115.
  41. Ludes B. Continuous river monitoring of the diatoms in the diagnosis of drowning / B. Ludes, M. Coste, A. Tracqui [et al.] // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 1996. – № 41. – R. 425–428.
  42. Thakar M. K. Diatomological mapping of water bodies for the diagnosis of drowning cases / M. K. Thakar, R. Singh // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2010. – № 17. – R. 18–25.
  43. Byard R. W. Vitreous humor sodium levels in immersion deaths / R. W. Byard, G. Summersides // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2011. – № 56. – R. 643–644.
  44. Modell J. H. Electrolyte changes in human drowning victims / J. H. Modell, J. H. Davis // Anesthesiology. – 1969. – № 30. – R. 414–420.
  45. Byard R. W. Haemolytic staining of the intima of the aortic root – a useful pathological marker of freshwater drowning? / R. W. Byard, G. Cains, M. Tsokos // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2006. – № 13. – R. 125–128.
  46. Ingham A. I. The potential significance of elevated vitreous sodium levels at autopsy / A. I. Ingham, R. W. Byard // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2009. – № 16. – R. 437–440.
  47. Gusencov A. O. Obnaruzhenie trupa v vode: osobennosti provedeniya osmotra mesta proisshestviya i naznacheniya sudebno-medicinskoj ekspertizy / A. O. Gusencov // Ugolovnyj process i kriminalistika: istoriya i so-vremennost': kriminalist. chteniya pamyati zasluzhennogo deyatelya nauki Respubliki Belarus', d-ra yuridicheskih nauk, prof. N. I. Porubova : materialy Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. (Minsk, 3 dek. 2015 g.). – Minsk, 2015. – Ch. 2. – S. 82–85.
  48. Didkovskaya S. P. Maceraciya kozhi v sudebno-medicinskom otnoshenii / S. P. Didkovskaya // Vtoraya rasshirennaya nauchnaya konferenciya. Kievskoe otdelenie UNOSM i K. – Kiev, 1958. – S. 72-73.
  49. Hohlov V. V. Sudebnaya medicina: Rukovodstvo / V. V. Hohlov, L. E. Kuznecov. – Smolensk, 1998. – 800 s.
  50. Permyakov A. V. Sudebno-medicinskaya gistologiya. Rukovodstvo dlya vrachej. (Izdanie vtoroe, pererabotannoe i dopolnennoe). / A. V. Permyakov, V. I. Viter, N. I. Nevolin. – Izhevsk-Ekaterinburg : «Ekspertiza», 2003. – 214 s.
  51. Chikun V. I. K voprosu ustanovleniya mesta i vremeni utopleniya v presnoj vode na osnove rezul'tatov diatomovogo analiza / V. I. Chikun, V. I. Lysyj, A. Yu. Karachev, Yu. V. Sharojkin // Sibirskij medicinskij zhurnal. – Irkutsk, 2005. – T. 57, № 7. – S. 68-72.
  52. Altaeva A. Zh. Usovershenstvovanie metodiki obnaruzheniya diatomovogo planktona v trupe pri ekspertize utopleniya / A. Zh. Altaeva, F. A. Galickij, A. Sh. Ajdarkulov. – 2013. – T. 56, № 1. – S. 35-38.
  53. Avdeev M. I. Sudebnaya medicina. Izdanie pyatoe / M. I. Avdeev. – Moskva: Gosyurizdat, 1960. – 539 s.
  54. Cipkovskij V. P. Osmotr mesta proisshestviya i trupa na meste ego obnaruzheniya / V. P. Cipkovskij. – Kiev : Gosudarstvennoe medicinskoe izdatel'stvo USSR, 1960 g. – 320 s.
  55. Bloch-Bogusławska E. The effect of the duration of corpse immersion on the occurrence of selected morphological findings / E. Bloch-Bogusławska, A. Paradowska, K. Piecyk //Archiwum Medycyny Sadowej i Kryminologii. – 2008. – Vol. 58, № 4. – P. 155-159.
  56. Pat. 946498 Soyuz Sovetskih Socialisticheskih Respublik. Sposob opredeleniya davnosti prebyvaniya trupa v vode / Sh. A. Selimhanov, P. M. Yusufov; zayavitel' i patentoobladatel' Sh. A. Selimhanov, P. M. Yus-ufov. – № 2813821/28-13; zayavl. 27.06.1979; opubl. 30.07.1982, Byul. № 28. – 2 s.
  57. Lazareva N. A. Sudebno-medicinskoe znachenie izmeneniya volos pri reshenii voprosa dlitel'nosti prebyvaniya tela v vode / N. A. Lazareva, I. A. Volosevich // Medicina zavtrashnego dnya : Materialy XIX mezhregional'noj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii studentov i molodyh uchenyh, Chita, 19–22 maya 2020 goda. – Chita : Chitinskaya gosudarstvennaya medicinskaya akademiya, 2020. – S. 299-300.
  58. Smol'yaninov V. M. Sudebnaya medicina: Uchebnik / V. M. Smol'yaninov. – 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. – M.: Medicina, 1982. – 464 s.
  59. Ten'kov A. A. Sudebno-medicinskaya ekspertiza trupa v pozdnie sroki postmortal'nogo perioda : (gnienie, zhirovosk, mumifikaciya, ocenka povrezhdenij) : monografiya / A. A. Ten'kov, V. O. Plaksin; Gos. obrazovat. uchrezhdenie vyssh. prof. obrazovaniya "Kur. gos. med. un-t Feder. agentstva po zdravoohraneniyu i soc. razvitiyu". – Kursk : Izd-vo Kurskogo gosudarstvennogo medicinskogo universiteta, 2005. – 419 s.
  60. Vavilov A. Yu. Ob impedansometricheskoj registracii izmeneniya elektroprovodnosti kozhnogo pokrova trupa v presnoj vode / A. Yu. Vavilov, I. A. Rykunov, A. V. Reshetov // Sovremennye problemy nauki i obrazovaniya. – 2023. – № 2.; URL: https://science-education.ru/ru/article/view?id=32465 (data obrashcheniya: 23.03.2023).
  61. Heaton V. Predicting the postmortem submersion interval for human remains recovered from U.K. waterways / V. Heaton, A. Lagden，C. Moffat [et al.] // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2010. – Vol. 55, № 2. – P. 302- 307.
  62. van Daalen M. A. An aquatic decomposition scoring method to potentially predict the postmortem submersion interval of bodies recovered from the North Sea / M. A. van Daalen, D. S. de Kat., B. F. Grotebevelsborg [et al.] // Journal of Forensic Sciences. – 2017 – Vol. 62. – № 2. – P. 369-373.
  63. Palazzo C. Application of aquatic decomposition scores for the deter-mination of the post mortem submersion interval on human bodies recovered from the Northern Adriatic Sea / C. Palazzo, G. Pelletti, P. Fais [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – Vol. 318. – 2021; [electronic resource] - URL: https://www.sci-encedirect.com/journal/forensic-science-international.
  64. Humphreys M. K. Comparison of protocols for measuring and calculating postmortem submersion intervals for human analogs in fresh water / M. K. Humphreys, E. Panacek, W. Green [et al.] //Journal of forensic sciences. – 2013. – Vol. 58, №. 2. – S. 513-517.
  65. Humphreys, M. K. Examination of histological samples from sub-merged carrion to aid in the determination of postmortem submersion interval / M. K. Humphreys, E. Panacek, W. Green [et al.] // American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. – 2013. – Vol. 34, № 1 – P. 75-79.
  66. Cartozzo C. Postmortem submersion interval (PMSI) estimation from the microbiome of sus scrofa bone in a freshwater river / C. Cartozzo, T. Simmons, J. Swall [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2021. – Vol. 318; [electronic resource] - URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/forensic-science-interna-tional.
  67. Thakar M. K. Diatomological mapping of water bodies for the diagnosis of drowning cases / M. K. Thakar, S. Rajvinder // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2010. – Vol. 17, № 1. – P. 18-25.
  68. Matyshev A. A. Osmotr trupa na meste ego obnaruzheniya: Rukovodstvo dlya vrachej / A. A. Matyshev. – L. : Medicina, 1989. – 264 s.
  69. Pirtle D. Barnacle colonization of shoes: Evaluation of a novel approach to estimate the time spent in water of human remains / D. Pirtle, P. A. Magni, G. W. Reinecke [et al.] // Forensic Science International. – 2019. – Vol. 294. – P. 1-9.
  70. Lyabzina S. N. Ekologiya kompleksa nekrofil'nyh bespozvonochnyh Severo-Zapada evropejskoj chasti Rossii : special'nost' 03.02.08 «Ekologiya» : avtoref. dis. … d-ra. biol. Nauk / Lyabzina Svetlana Nikolaevna. – Moskva, 2018. – 50 s.
  71. Prozorovskij V. I. Sudebnaya medicina / V. I. Prozorovskij. – M.: «Yuridicheskaya literatura», 1968. – 368 s.
  72. Chajka S. Yu. Sudebnaya entomologiya : Ucheb. posobie / S. Yu. Chajka: Mosk. gos. un-t im. M.V. Lomonosova. – Moskva : MAKS Press, 2003. – 60 s.
  73. Dalal J. Seasonal study of the decomposition pattern and insects on a submerged pig cadaver / J. Dalal, S. Sharma, T. Bhardwaj [et al.] // Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine. – 2020. – Vol. 74; [electronic resource] - URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/journal-of-forensic-and-legal-medicine.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download

Copyright (c) Eco-Vector


СМИ зарегистрировано Федеральной службой по надзору в сфере связи, информационных технологий и массовых коммуникаций (Роскомнадзор).
Регистрационный номер и дата принятия решения о регистрации СМИ: серия ПИ № ФС 77 - 81753 выдано 09.09.2021 г. 
СМИ зарегистрировано Федеральной службой по надзору в сфере связи, информационных технологий и массовых коммуникаций (Роскомнадзор).
Регистрационный номер и дата принятия решения о регистрации СМИ: серия ЭЛ № ФС 77 – 59181 выдано 03.09.2014 г.